AZHOC - Arizona Homeowners Coalition
Voice for homeowner rights and justice.

Single Blog Title

This is a single blog caption

Can HOA restrict street parking on public street?

I’ve contacted the Mesa City Planners office, and the Mesa Tax Commissioners office and both state the street I live on E Elena Ave in Mesa is a public street, the signs on the street also say city of mesa, which is another indication of a public street, yet my HOA is still issuing $50 fines to residences for vehicles parking on the street in front of resident’s home, Additionaly the registration of the vehicles is not checked.
I was fined for a vehicle that was not registered to anyone who lives in my houshold. How do I get them to stop issuing these fines, and refund homeowners the fines that the HOA has issued?

1 Response

  1. Dennis Legere

    Mike;

    HOA’s have a fundamental right to write rules to control their common property, that is property that they actually own. However developers and their attorneys have frequently expanded that authority by simply adding in the CC&R’s restrictions on parking on streets that they do not own. If challenged in court these CC&R provisions would be found invalid on the grounds that they violate public policy. The city owns the streets they and only they can regulate those streets. I will not that if the CC&R’s do not specifically authorize street parking restrictions the association is not free to write rules that are not authorized in the CC&R’s. In 2016 the Arizona legislature made this fact clear, banning any planned community to place restrictions on the uses of streets owned by municipalities. See ARS 33-1818. The only problem with that legislation is that it grand fathered any CC&R restriction that existed prior to the enactment of that legislation. however if any change to the CC&R is recorded for any reason the provision on roadway restrictions are invalidated immediately.
    So to answer your specific question what you can do depends on your specific CC&R’s. If they contain clear restrictions on street parking than the only course of action you can take is to challenge the legitimacy of that restriction in Superior court with the assistance of a attorney competent in property servitude law, on the ground of “violating public policy”. If your CC&R’s contain no such restrictions but your association has enacted rules limiting parking on public streets then they are violating Arizona law and you can challenge that with a petition to the Arizona Department of Real Estate.

    hopefully this helps
    Dennis

Leave a Reply